In the weeks leading up to the 2018 NFL Draft, anticipation ran high as top prospects prepared to begin their professional careers. With the No. 5 overall pick, the Denver Broncos faced a crucial decision that could shape the franchise's future. Ultimately, the Broncos selected Bradley Chubb, a defensive standout from North Carolina State. Meanwhile, the Buffalo Bills selected quarterback Josh Allen with the No. 8 overall pick. As the years passed, these decisions came under scrutiny, especially when reflecting on what might have been for Denver.
Broncos' Gamble on Chubb
Bradley Chubb quickly proved his worth on the Broncos' defensive line. Over the course of his tenure with the team, Chubb played in 49 games, recording 144 tackles, 26 sacks, and even an interception. These impressive stats culminated in his selection to the Pro Bowl, highlighting his dominant presence on the field. However, despite his individual success, team performance in Denver remained inconsistent.
While Chubb's contributions on defense were significant, the Broncos struggled to find a stable and dynamic quarterback to lead the team. This struggle is outlined by none other than John Elway, the former Broncos General Manager. Reflecting on the Broncos' 2018 draft decision, Elway candidly admitted, "That was probably my biggest mistake of my GM days, was not taking Josh ... And I loved him, right? … he was my type." His admission underscores the weight of their choice, one that would be scrutinized through the lens of Allen's subsequent success in Buffalo.
Josh Allen's Rise
Josh Allen's career with the Buffalo Bills took off in a way that exceeded many expectations. Leading the Bills to four consecutive AFC East titles since 2020, Allen cemented his role as one of the most dynamic quarterbacks in the NFL. His leadership and remarkable athleticism brought a new era of success to Buffalo, a team traditionally overshadowed in a competitive division.
Allen's ascension was not lost on Elway. Describing a golf encounter with the star quarterback, Elway shared a memorable moment: "Last year I played golf with him, and I'm wondering, how long is it going to take him to realize that I passed on him and took Bradley Chubb instead? And it took him two-and-a-half holes." It’s a poignant reminder of the 'what-ifs' that linger in the NFL draft history.
Chubb's Transition
After a notable career in Denver, Bradley Chubb was traded to the Miami Dolphins. His move brought mixed feelings to Broncos fans, who appreciated his contributions but were also eager for a more effective rebuild strategy, particularly at the quarterback position. As Chubb continues his career in Miami, he brings his proven skills and experience to a team looking to bolster its defense.
The narratives of Bradley Chubb and Josh Allen exemplify the unpredictable and often high-stakes nature of the NFL Draft. For the Denver Broncos, the decision to pick Chubb over Allen is a reflection of strategy, potential, and, as Elway admitted, perhaps a significant oversight. Meanwhile, the Buffalo Bills' choice has paid dividends, transforming their team into persistent contenders under Allen's leadership.
In retrospect, draft decisions provide endless material for analysis and debate. They pose enduring questions about scouting, decision-making, and the inherent uncertainty of predicting future success in such a competitive league. For fans and analysts alike, the stories of Chubb and Allen offer a compelling case study in the art and science of building a championship-caliber team.